A Review of This One We Call Ours by Martha Silano
This One We Call Ours
by Martha Silano
Lynx House Press, 2024.
How does a poet tackle climate change, the daily destruction of life on our planet? How do we balance doom and gloom with resolve and reverence? Enter Martha Silano’s new book, This One We Call Ours, winner of the Blue Lynx Poetry Prize. Silano brings an intimate knowledge of the natural world and her prowess as a poet to evoke our deepest feelings of grief and love for our Earth and all its inhabitants.
Silano puts us in our proper place right from the start. In her prologue poem, “What They Said,” we are reminded that our planet is one among 100 billion, a tiny speck in the universe. But she situates us there from her stance as a fellow human, trying to grasp what all this immensity means: “all these words / I didn’t understand.” In a book full of the science of creation and extinction, we are invited to learn and marvel right along with the poet.
Silano sets her readers face to face with the reality of all that has already, irrevocably, been lost. In “At the Burke Museum,” she writes: “I’m woozy with the ramshackle mess of miracle, catastrophe, / impermanence−how suddenly a species can be gone.” She lays it on the line in “Love Song for the Anthropocene":
This is the epoch of No Plan B,
of the Speckled Wood’s early emergence, before the cock’s foot and Yorkshire fog
have bloomed. How this poem ends is not with a miracle,
the Hula painted frog found thriving, not extinct.
Our state of wonder will sink or be singed. Our dominance dactyl
replaced by a spate of spondees:
we are so, so f**ked.
Clever as always, Silano makes me smile even at this dire pronouncement, as she switches from the meter of the dactyl to the last line in pounding spondees.
Just when we think we can’t bear one more bit of evidence of our coming extinction, Silano assuages us with humor. In “After Apple Picking, Late Anthropocene,” considering the time after humans have destroyed ourselves, we get “Mother Earth / will heave a great sigh, crack open a Bud.” Some of the humor is dark, like the section titles where she renames the seasons, e.g., “Carry an Inhaler, Stuck Indoors with Air Purifiers, Air Quality Index Apps Season (formerly autumn).” Some is wild understatement, some breathtaking leaps from the cosmos to the kitchen sink. In “Nine Billion Years After the Big Bang,” she explains the origin of Earth:
the Earth began to form when gravity pulled together swirling gas and dust.
It sounds so easy, doesn’t it? Gravity plus dust equals a planet
so many of us have a soft spot for.
I wish I could tell you how we got from gravity and dust
to hoodoos and the Gobi Desert, to the Rockies
and the Mississippi gopher frog.
It’s like writing an email to someone you haven’t seen in forty years,
trying your best to catch them up. So yeah, it took a while,
but it finally cooled […]
[…] No matter how much you try to cram into that missive,
You’ll never capture how you got from 20 to 60,
From a roach-ridden one-room studio
in Portland to what all else ensued […]
Silano is a masterful poet, author of five previous books and winner of many prizes. She uses all her mastery to reach us, to break through ignorance, ennui, nonchalance about what is happening before our eyes. Her images are unexpected and completely devoid of sentimentality: “[…] On the inside / I’m just me: heart beating / like a garbage truck backing up your street.” She employs anaphora and irony, as in “Happy Holidays from the Everglades,” where the repetition of “I give you” beats a dreadful drumming into our ears: all this beauty and all this destruction are ours to own. She writes from the point of view of an orca in “Self-Portrait as Southern Resident Orca”; if we won’t heed scientists or activists, would we please listen to the voice of the orca?
I once heard a poet say that to write about hard topics, the writing must be beautiful, or no one will want to read it. Silano indeed makes it beautiful. She takes scientific information and shares it with us so that the stunning realities of our world emerge. She praises this earth we get to live on, as in “Why I Love to Garden in My Front Yard”:
because honeybees found their way into each starry bloom.
[…]
[…] Because
a neighbor stopped by to chat, said squash blossoms
are a delicacy, showed me how to dip them in a mixture
of beer and flour, fry them in oil. Because we’re biting into sunshine.
Silano sprinkles these poems of praise throughout the book, so our appreciation of our planet and the ordinary pleasures it brings lives alongside our despair and grief.
While Silano doesn’t allow us to indulge in unwarranted optimism, there are also glimmers of hope, especially when she interacts with children. One of my favorite poems is “Chaperoning My Son’s Marine Biology Field Trip on the 49th Earth Day.” She perfectly riffs off Walt Whitman’s “When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer” to plead for space for the students to explore and wonder about our Earth instead of being told to stick to the “laminated list of habitat types.” The kids aren’t daunted, though:
[…] My doom-spewing trap is shut as one kid shouts Get over here, you guys!
It’s a nudibranch! And there it is, on a giant rock smothered in rainbow-leaf seaweed.
I forget about moose-killing ticks, doomed Puerto Rican iguacas, skin-diseased
dolphins, the diminished leks of prairie chickens, revel in their awe.
Towards the end of the book, Silano allows herself a moment to hope that humans could forget greed and small-mindedness and change the trajectory we’re on. In “If We Were Not So Single-Minded” she writes:
[…] there must be a way to save us
from ourselves. There must be a cloud or shroud
or asteroid belt, a minor planet that can knock us back
onto a non-deadly trajectory. Neruda suggests
we should all stop. Imagine if we all
did, walked out into late afternoon light to greet
small pink blooms on a gnarled tree
in a yard that could be anyone’s.
Silano’s love for the natural world and for all beings in it leads her to rely most of all on our connections, as in the penultimate poem, “We Are All Magnificent”:
[…] We are all the nothingness
after a white dwarf dies. We are all the stiff wind/and the slack,…
[…]
In our bones, bits of stars.
[…]
Some of us live under a mossy roof, somewhere monsoons
soak adobe brick. We’re mostly hydrogen and oxygen.
Sometimes we’re less garbage gyre, more string quartet.
Sometimes we take a catastrophe, turn it into a kiss.
Silano doesn’t make a direct call to action in her book, but in reading it, how could we not be moved? As we enter an even more perilous period that could seal the deal on extinction, I hope Silano’s words stir many people to activism and inspire those who are already engaged. Read this book in your book club, even if the members don’t think they like poetry. Gift it to your neighbors, regardless of their politics. And all the while, love the squash blossom, bite into sunshine.